What are the Best Baby Mattresses?

Guide, Features and Prices

👋 Hey! Before you read the article we just wanted to say thank you. Your on-going support, love and feedback on our articles as well as browsing our independently picked recommendations (which earn us a commission and help pay our passionate writing team) keep this little independently owned business going. So again, thank you. We look forward to showing you the magic we can bring in 2018!

Having a baby requires a lot of thinking and a lot of decision making! One of those is choosing a baby mattress. Yes, it might seem quite simple but nothing is ever as simple as it seems, right? Baby mattresses actually have a quite significant role because the comfort, stability, and safety are the most important things for every parent and baby. Your newborn can sleep up to 18 hours and if the mattress is uncomfortable or inappropriate, there can be a lot of serious consequences!

Choosing a Baby Mattress

If you are choosing a baby mattress for a crib, the first thing you should consider is, of course, the size. It has to fit the crib perfectly because being squished or leaving gaps on the sides could harm your baby when turning around. You should also find a firm mattress because choosing a soft one is not recommended in this case. It could affect the shape of baby’s head, face and even put it at the risk of suffocation and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Therefore, avoid mattresses that your baby could sink in.

Generally, mattresses are divided into two groups – innerspring and foam. Both of these types can be a good choice if they are high-quality products. However, there are a few differences between them. The biggest one is the weight. Foam mattresses are generally lighter (5 to 30 pounds) than innerspring mattresses (15 to 30 pounds). For that reason, foam mattress is easier to move and cannot be used as a trampoline afterward, which kids mostly end up doing with innerspring mattresses.

Related image

Quality Matters the Most

Regardless of the mattress type you end up getting for your child, the most important factor is its quality. If you opt for the cheapest mattress with thin coverings and edgings, you will see the signs of tearing, cracking and drying out very soon. Baby mattresses of better quality have thicker covers, reinforced laminates, they are puncture or/and water resistant, they will last for long and will be supported by best materials from the inside and on the surface.

The prices usually range from $50 to $400, depending on what you are looking for. If you are determined to buy a baby mattress made from natural latex or organic cotton, you will have to save a good amount of money. However, a regular baby mattress that will satisfy the essential needs and support your infant properly ranges from $90 to $200. You can find great products for an affordable price that will ensure safety and comfort for you and your baby on Amazon. We did the work for you and found the best 10 baby mattresses that you should consider!

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress

This product qualifies as one of the best recommended but also most expensive baby mattresses on Amazon. Once you get into the specifications, you can understand its price and the good reviews. This is a standard size (51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches) mattress that fits all regular cribs and toddler beds. It has the toughest GREENGUARD standard, which confirms it passes over 10,000 volatile organic compounds and all requirements for indoor air quality.

Due to its dual firmness, it is a great support for infants and toddlers, avoiding any possible risk of suffocation. It might not be 100% organic but according to Colgate’s official website, it is CertiPUR-US Certified and made from the oil plants of highest quality. On top of all these elements, this baby mattress is waterproof.

Pros

GREENGUARD Children & Schools Certified
Waterproof
Organic

Cons

Moderately expensive
Possibly makes sounds while moving


Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

As mentioned above, foam mattress is very popular amongst new or expecting parents so we are not surprised by the number of orders and positive reviews for this product. It uses the renewable soybeans that assist in creating a firm foam, which is extremely important for your toddler. It is lightweight (8.3 pounds) so you will not struggle moving it around when cleaning or changing the cover.

The dimensions (51.6 x 27.2 x 5 inches) are perfect for most cribs and the surface is waterproof so you won’t have to deep-wash the mattress after your baby wets it.

Pros

Lightweight (8.3 pounds)
Waterproof
High-Density Soybean Foam-Core

Cons

Sinks over time
Not breathable


Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress

Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress | Hypoallergenic + Waterproof Encasement | 27.5"x52"x5.5"

Another baby mattress made of foam that captured our attention due to plenty of good reviews and an extremely affordable price is Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress! According to the feedback on Amazon, it is better and comfier than triple more expensive products. If you are on a budget, you might purchase exactly this one. It is described as comfortable and safe for babies and toddlers, with some incredible features. One of them is a perfect air flow on the bottom, the encasement made of anti-flame materials, it is completely chemicals free, hypoallergenic and waterproof!

Similarly to all high-quality baby mattresses, it is CertiPUR-US Certified, which ensures you are making a good choice if purchasing this product. It has standard dimensions (52 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches) so you can freely take the time and check this one on Amazon, read the description and comments yourself and make a final decision.

Pros

Hypoallergenic
Waterproof
Moderately cheap

Cons

Needs over 24 hours to get to its real size
Takes time to dry


My First Crib Mattress, Memory Foam Crib Mattress

My First Crib Mattress, Memory Foam Crib Mattress, Removable Waterproof Cover, Plush, Hypoallergenic

Just when you think that it’s already too hard to choose between the mattresses listed above, we have a new great offer! Memory foam is a frequent and highly requested core of the mattress. This one has several points that make it stand out from the rest. It includes a removable waterproof cover, plush and hypoallergenic features that attract customers immediately. According to the rating on Amazon (4.3 stars), most of the people are actually satisfied after trying it out.

You can choose either a plain or quilted design in standard dimensions, filled with flexible polyurethane foam that will contribute to a long and comfortable sleep of your baby. It is anti-microbial, mite-proof, and lead free, meets federal flammability and CPSC standards and is CertiPUR-US Certified. My First Crib Mattress comes with 10-year warranty, which means you might even be able to use it for a couple of new babies!

Pros

Hypoallergenic
Removable waterproof cover

Cons

Needs over 72 hours to get to its real size
Might result softer than expected


Colgate Classica I – Lightweight Foam Crib Mattress

Colgate Classica I - Lightweight Foam Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover, White

The second product from Colgate made a way to our list but this time it is Classica I. This 5″ baby mattress is a solid support made of firm foam that ensures proper development of your little ones. Similarly to all the high-quality mattresses, we explored through this article, Colgate Classica I is CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold Certified and received a lot of praising comments that would make anyone want to buy it.

In case you don’t especially want a specific color to match the room of your toddler, this classic-looking white mattress will fit any crib of a standard size. You can change the waterproof cover as often as you like. Some of the customers even said they are ordering a second one for a new baby since the first mattress turned out to be great. Therefore, you should definitely try it out and perhaps repeat that story!

Pros

Lightweight (8 pounds)
Waterproof cover
Durable

Cons

Possibly too firm


Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress

 

A new, serious candidate on this list is Dream On Me, a mattress made in the USA with some pretty impressive elements! It is made of 10% Vinyl and 90% Foam, it is easily affordable and the seller is ranked as #1 on Amazon! By that, consider that you can safely make your purchase without any second thoughts. This mattress is antibacterial, waterproof and comes with a 30 days warranty. Therefore, if anything noticeable happens in the first month after the delivery, you can return it and buy some of the other products suggested in this post.

It is slightly smaller than the mattresses we inspected so far (38 x 26 x 3 inches) and very light (3.5 pounds). That being said, measure the dimensions of the crib or decide how exactly you are going to use this mattress beforehand.

As the name suggest, you can simply buy it for a playtime with your baby! It will surely enjoy rolling around on this comfortable mattress but make sure you placed it correctly against the wall or crib sides to avoid any harm.

Pros

Lightweight (3.5 pounds)
Sturd
Portable

Cons

Possibly too firm
Too small for standard-sized cribs


Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

The Dual Side Sleep System makes a great implementation to the quality and comfort of this mattress. We noticed that the creators were really careful with the creation of this product. They used a medical and durable stretch knit fabric with extra tight sewn seams that eliminates the risk of toxic flame-retardant chemicals. Creators point out that it is very easy to clean (you know how important that is) due to its waterproof and hypoallergenic material.

This product comes directly from the USA and promises a lot! If instead of the price, quality is your priority, you might as well read more about this baby matters. We are sure you will like it as much as we did.

Pros

Dual Side Sleep System
Medical Grade Fabric
Easy to clean
Portable

Cons

Moderately expensive


Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress 

Serta Tranquility is the first innerspring mattress on our list. In contrary to the foam, innerspring is heavier and not as easy to move around but it surely has its benefits! As for this specific type, it seems extremely durable and comfortable with an ortho-insulated layer for support. It does not contain toxic fire retardants and meets or exceeds lead, flammability, phthalate and CPSIA testing.

What makes innerspring attractive is that it’s not meant only for babies but even for parents. For that reason, innerspring mattresses are more popular in the USA. However, the dimensions of this product (52 x 27.5 x 6 inches) won’t exactly allow you to sleep on it but you can surely play with your kid while sitting together. The square corners make it easier to fit the crib and naturally blended cotton layer on toddler side will surely make your baby sleep over the whole night without waking you up every half an hour.

Pros

Full perimeter border wire
Durable

Cons

Heavy
Possibly too firm


If you are the type that paints the room all blue or all pink for your baby, we have great news for you! White is not your only option anymore because Safety 1st also comes in pink and light blue. The whole brand is inspired by heavenly motives so just a look at this mattress makes us think of sweet baby dreams! The core is high-density thermo-bonded and very light (7.5 pounds), GREENGUARD CERTIFIED and meets federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633, which ensures it doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals.

Customers describe it as pretty good and recommend it to people who are not willing to spend too much money on a mattress but still need a decent product.

Pros

Lightweight (7.5 pounds)
Comes in different colors
Hypoallergenic

Cons

Loses shape over time


Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Last but not least, on our top 10 baby mattresses list comes from Graco. We chose this mattress after analyzing its materials, benefits, and reviews. It is anti-microbial, anti-static and free of phthalates, meets federal flammability standards and ensures the safety of your infant. In case you decide to purchase it, you will need to wait around 48 hours until it fully expands since it’s shipped in a compressed small box for better and faster arrival.

This product is made of breathable, 5’’ thick foam and offers a 6-year warranty! With everything on paper, we think that you surely should consider this product if you’re looking for a regular, standard-sized mattress for your baby.

Pros

Lightweight (7 pounds)
Water-resistant inner-lining

Cons

Needs over 72 hours to get to its real size


Check out all the best baby mattresses in the table below

Product NameImagePriceFeaturesRating
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress$$$Dual Side Sleep System, Medical Grade Fabric, Easy to Clean, Portable½
Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress, Organic Cotton Cover$$$Waterproof, Certified Organic Cotton Cover, Dual Firmness,
Eco Foam Infused with Plant Oils
½
Colgate Classica I - Lightweight Foam Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover$$$Waterproof, 5" Thick, Extra-firm, Lightweight½
Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress$$Innerspring Coils, Ortho-insulated Layer, Heavy, Cotton Layer on Toddler Side½
My First Crib Mattress, Memory Foam Crib Mattress$$Waterproof, Soft Cover, Hypoallergenic, Phthalate and Lead free, Mite-proof, Anti-microbial, ½
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress$$High-Density Soybean Foam-Core, Waterproof Surface and Binding
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress$$High-density Thermo-bonded Fiber Core, Hypoallergenic, Lightweight, Vinyl Cover
Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress$Waterproof, Made of Unique Blend of Foam, Advanced Air Flow, Chemicals Free½
Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress$3'' Thick, Waterproof, Foam 90% / Vinyl 10%, Antibacterial, Accommodates Babies 3.45 Pounds½

Conclusion

There is no doubt that you only want the best for your infant and mattress takes a big part in how the head and body of your baby will shape, the quality of your baby’s sleep and well-being. It also plays a significant role in potential fatal risks that your child might experience. Therefore, it is extremely important to choose an appropriate mattress.

We offered 10 best products with best reviews and a combination of beneficial features. Our goal is to assist new and expecting moms in the best way possible and we would be happy to hear from you after purchasing any of these products and confirming that we made a right choice!

 

Please read our other reviews too

The Best Baby Activity Tables

Best Baby Jumpers

Top 5 Baby Fences

Written by Anonymous Post

This account is one we use for all writers who wish to remain anonymous by request. For us, it's important to keep this hidden publicly. If you'd like to see who wrote the piece feel free to write in.

bassinet

Best Baby Bassinets

baby-tub-bath

Best Baby Bathtubs